Can AI prepare the information your employees need correctly and save them time? An AI proof of concept is a small experiment to answer that question before you invest in a full system. Test a simple prototype on real examples and let employees try it. The results give you evidence for deciding what to develop further and when to change direction or stop.
First, check whether the potential savings justify an automation experiment. We’ll use a hypothetical logistics company as a running example. Its employees receive shipment requests and transfer information into internal systems. The experiment tests whether AI can reduce that manual entry without introducing incorrect records.
What does success mean for your AI proof of concept?
Before building anything, discuss the inputs and intended outcome with the employees who handle the task today. In our example, which information do they transfer from a shipment request into internal systems? Pick a real request and work through what a good result would look like. Extracted addresses and requested dates should match the request, while missing or unclear details should lead to employee review instead of a guess.
Then agree what would make that result useful in daily work. If an employee still needs to check the extracted information, can they do that faster than entering everything manually? That gives you a goal for the proof of concept: correctly prepare the information and reduce the time spent entering it. You now have something concrete to test.
Establish which data we can use
Before choosing tools, agree who may access the data and where processing may happen. Include the instructions sent to the model, known as prompts, alongside its outputs and any information recorded for debugging. Hosted models can simplify experiments when their terms meet your requirements, while keeping data within your infrastructure adds operational work. Removing personal information is an option, but the examples must still represent the task you are testing.
Collect a representative sample of shipment requests, with enough examples to estimate how often problems occur. Include familiar formats alongside poor scans and requests with missing information, especially cases that require human review. A large collection of similar requests cannot replace coverage of important failures.
Define reference answers together
Engineers and employees who know the process review the examples together and record checked reference answers, often called ground truth. That discussion also tests our understanding of your business. If a request contains both a sender’s office address and a delivery address, agree which belongs in each part of the result before scoring the model’s output.
If a date is unreadable, the correct result may be a request for human review rather than a guessed date. Include that expected response in the reference answers so the evaluation rewards asking for help when needed.
Other tasks, such as drafting customer replies, can have different valid answers. For those, define a rubric that explains what a good result must contain and which mistakes are unacceptable, with examples. Another AI model can act as a judge and assess outputs against the rubric, but check its agreement with human reviewers before relying on its scores.
Set up evaluation before improving the prototype
Automated evaluation means repeatedly running examples through the system and checking its outputs against the agreed reference answers. For our shipment requests, check whether it extracts the addresses and dates correctly and flags unclear information for review. Keep changes to live internal systems outside the initial experiment, and check that the prototype only prepares information for employees to inspect. Report important failures separately, with examples, because an average score can hide repeated mistakes in delivery addresses.
Keep some requests out of the examples engineers use while improving the prototype. Test on these reserved requests to check whether improvements also work on examples outside day-to-day development. The more representative they are, the more confidence you can have that results will hold in daily work. Add new formats and errors as you discover them, and repeat runs to check inconsistent behaviour.
Engineers can then work independently against agreed checks while your team reviews important findings. Our technical guide to structured evaluation pipelines explains how to build the evaluation.
Test a simple first version
Build a simple first version with existing software and models within the agreed constraints. We prefer open-source software and open standards, with components we can replace. Compare the prototype against today’s process and simpler alternatives. Fixed rules may extract information from a standard request form, while AI can help interpret requests written in different ways.
Run the first version through the evaluation before trying to improve it. These initial measurements are your baseline for judging later changes. Even poor results help you identify what needs work and whether AI justifies its added complexity.
Let employees try the workflow early
Let employees try sample shipment requests in the prototype without changing live records. Watch how they check the original request and correct extracted information, and compare review time with manual entry.
A model can score well without saving time. If employees must open three other systems to check every result, you may need changes to the interface and workflow as well as better extraction. Use what employees tell you and the evaluation results to decide what to improve next.
Improve against the evidence and agree when to stop
Choose experiments based on the failures you find. Poor extraction from a scan might call for better document preparation, while misunderstood fields may need clearer instructions. You can also test extra software checks or another model. Record each change and compare it with the baseline on the same evaluation.
Keep changes that improve the agreed outcomes without introducing unacceptable failures. A cheaper model may be enough if it does the job, whereas a higher average score does not help if it comes with mistakes employees cannot catch.
Decide what the evidence supports:
- Continue when the prototype produces the agreed results and employees find it useful, identifying the integration and operational work needed next.
- Change direction when a smaller scope or different workflow offers more value, such as preparing records for approval instead of creating them automatically.
- Stop when the likely savings do not justify development, review, and maintenance, or when the approach cannot meet important requirements.
For inconclusive results, explain what remains uncertain and compare the cost of another test with the value of resolving it. Do not keep improving a score without checking the business value.
Keep the evaluation data, code, and findings available for future decisions, as we discuss in how to make your automation investment last. Employees also gain practical intuition about where AI helps and what needs checking, with experience of how automation fits their work. That learning remains useful even if you change direction or stop. A successful prototype still needs work to become a production system, with scope agreed separately.
Frequently asked questions
How much evaluation data do we need?
You need coverage of expected inputs and important failures, with enough volume to make useful comparisons. Start with what you have and expand it as you identify gaps. A small selected sample can support an early experiment, but gives limited evidence about everyday reliability.
Can we start with a prototype and add evaluation later?
An initial experiment can help clarify an unfamiliar task, but establish reference answers and basic evaluation before optimising it. Otherwise, you have no consistent way to judge whether changes help.
Does passing the evaluation mean the system is ready for production?
No. It provides evidence about the cases and requirements you tested. Production use also needs suitable security, integration, monitoring, and recovery, plus checks that performance holds on real work.